Say what you want about A.J. Preller’s offseason, the haul he received for Craig Kimbrel alone went a long ways toward beefing up the Padres’ depleted farm system.
Nevertheless, the second-year general manager still has a long road to hoe.
Even with the shortstop and center fielder of the future finally in hand (or so Preller hopes), the Padres’ farm system ranks 26th in the majors, according to Baseball America’s just-published Prospect Handbook. Though certainly improved via offseason trades, the organization comes in ahead of the Tigers, Orioles, Mariners, Marlins and Angels in its lowest ranking in at least the previous five years.
Baseball America’s assessment:
“The trade that brought Javier Guerra, Manuel Margot and Logan Allen to San Diego was a much-needed talent infusion that brought the Padres out of the talent rankings basement. Before San Diego’s Craig Kimbrel trade and the Angels trade that sent Sean Newcomb to the Braves, San Diego would have likely ranked 30th.”
That sentiment isn’t exactly flying in the face of earlier valuations.
Though three Padres farmhands landed on MLB.com’s top-100 prospects list, the organization was shut out of the site’s top-10 positional rankings and only had one player – center fielder Manuel Margot at No. 45 – land in the top 50. Shortstop Javier Guerra ranked 58th and outfielder Hunter Renfroe – a rare prospect holdover from the Josh Byrnes’ regime – sits at No. 92 after an inconsistent 2015 campaign.
He, too, ranked third among Baseball America’s assessment of Padres prospects behind Guerra and Margot.
A breakdown of the organization’s top 31 prospects follows (the early bird gets the supplement), including a telling write-up on the since DFA’d Rymer Liriano at No. 23: “At his best, Liriano has plus bat speed and above-average raw power. Though he was far more selective in 2015, he still strikes out too much with a long and hard swing that doesn’t produce enough power to justify the whiffs.”
Baseball America on Padres’ top prospects
Rk |
Player |
Comment |
1 |
SS Javier Guerra |
The organization’s shortstop of the future |
2 |
OF Manuel Margot |
Profiles as an everyday center fielder, if not an impact bat |
3 |
OF Hunter Renfroe |
A reputation for running hot and cold |
4 |
SS Ruddy Giron |
Above-average hitter with swing geared for line drives |
5 |
SS Jose Rondon |
Has glove to be a regular but the bat of a utility player |
6 |
OF Travis Jankowski |
Ceiling of a table-setting regular or possible reserve |
7 |
RHP Colin Rea |
Projects as a back of the rotation option |
8 |
LHP Logan Allen |
Command-over-stuff, back-end starter |
9 |
RHP Austin Smith |
3 pitches that have flashed at least average; fastball projects to be plus |
10 |
OF Michael Gettys |
Plus defender … double-plus speed … double-plus arm |
11 |
RHP Jacob Nix |
Easy fastball up to 95 mph, but secondary offerings are fringy at best |
12 |
RHP Cory Mazzoni |
Stuff ticked up after being moved to the bullpen |
13 |
2B/3B Carlos Asuaje |
A bat-first utility player who could be ready in 2016 |
14 |
RHP Ryan Butler |
An improved slider will help Butler miss more bats |
15 |
RHP Enyel De Los Santos |
Sits 93-95 mph, has touched 97; average curve and changeup that flashes plus |
16 |
RHP Tayron Guerrero |
Fastball touches 100 mph and slider that flashes plus |
17 |
RHP Dinelson Lamet |
Could move quickly as a reliever because he lacks a developed third pitch |
18 |
OF Nick Torres |
Best tool is his above-average raw power, but also has feel for hitting |
19 |
RHP Yimmi Brasoban |
Fastball shot from 90-94 as a starter to 97-98 with late sink in bullpen |
20 |
2B Fernando Perez |
A potent offensive second baseman as a ceiling |
21 |
2B/3B Jose Pirela |
High-energy presence, versatile rolep layer going forward |
22 |
OF/1B Alex Dickerson |
Big league option in a part-time role at first base or left field |
23 |
OF Rymer Liriano |
Strikes out too much with long swing that doesn’t produce enough power |
24 |
OF Jose Urena |
Plus raw power generated by quick hands |
25 |
RHP Justin Hancock |
Lacks breaking ball to have a regular rotation spot |
26 |
RHP Phil Maton |
Nees to reintroduce changeup to make it in the rotation |
27 |
LHP Jose Castillo |
Lack of reliable changeup might relegate Castillo to the bullpen |
28 |
LHP Jose Torres |
Still learning how to pitch as opposed to just throw |
29 |
SS/2B Luis Urias |
Contact-oriented approach; will always have below-average power |
30 |
RHP Emmanuel Ramirez |
Curveball rates as the best in the organization |
31 |
1B Brad Zunica |
Carrying tool is double-plus raw power |
jeff.sanders@sduniontribune.com; on Twitter: @sdutSanders