Lawyers representing New Jersey went to court Wednesday and made their latest argument that the state should be allowed to offer sports betting at casinos and horse-racing tracks.
Former U.S. Solicitor General Theodore Olson — who led a legal team that represented President George W. Bush in the disputed 2000 election — gave the bulk of the 30-minute argument on behalf of New Jersey at the Third Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia. It’s the most recent — and potentially last — attempt in New Jersey’s efforts to allow sports gambling.
Olson faced tough questions from the 12-judge panel on New Jersey’s attempt to comply with Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (PASPA) of 1992, sports and gambling law attorney Daniel L. Wallach told USA TODAY Sports.
“The court appeared skeptical,” said Wallach, who attended the hearing. “There were not many smiling faces when the lawyers for New Jersey left court.”
A decision isn’t expected for months.
The U.S. Attorney’s Office has contended even before New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie signed the disputed bill into law in 2014 that the state isn’t allowed to offer sports betting under the PASPA, a federal law that made state-sanctioned sports betting illegal in most states. (Nevada, Montana, Oregon and Delaware were grandfathered in.) A federal district court and then a three-judge panel at the Third Circuit Court of Appeals sided with feds, whose position on limiting sports betting had the backing of the NFL, MLB, NBA, NHL and NCAA.
That initial decision by the Third Circuit Court of Appeals announced in August was vacated when Wednesday’s en banc rehearing was granted in October.
New Jersey voters originally passed a law to legalize sports betting in the state in 2011 as a means to bolster flagging tourism in Atlantic City and aid the state’s racetracks. The fight has been obscured in recent months by the legal wrangling over daily fantasy sports, which was deemed illegal under state law in New York, Texas and other states.
“Atlantic City’s demise has been driven by the fact the casinos don’t have an attraction that would lead visitors to buy rooms, go out to dinner to see a show,” State Sen. Raymond Lesniak, a longtime backer of online and sports gambling, told USA TODAY Sports. “When they come to Atlantic City now, they usually go for just the day and not for a long weekend. To have an event like the Super Bowl where people can bet would be huge boost for Atlantic City. It’d also help put fannies in the seats at the race tracks.”
Christie signed the original law in 2012, but the effort was blocked in federal court. A reworked bill passed the state legislature and was signed by Christie two years ago.
Paul D. Clement, a former U.S. solicitor general who represents the leagues and the NCAA, led the government’s argument on Wednesday. Paul J. Fishman, the U.S. Attorney for the District of New Jersey, also argued New Jersey doesn’t have the legal standing to offer sports betting.
New Jersey could petition the U.S. Supreme Court if it loses the appeal, although it would be at the high court’s discretion to take up the case.
“That would be a Hail Mary,” Wallach said. “Less than one percent of those who file certs are heard by the Supreme Court. That would be New Jersey’s only option after today.”
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCA plea for perspective on Ronda Rousey’s suicide comments | 03:48
MMAjunkie’s Ben Fowlkes offers his thoughts on what Ronda Rousey said in front of millions on “Ellen” this week.
USA TODAY Sports
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCUFC 197: Daniel Cormier previews Jon Jones rematch | 02:08
Listen as the light heavyweight champ offers his thoughts on what will be different in April’s rematch.
USA TODAY Sports
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCUFC 196: McGregor-dos Anjos, Holm-Tate first faceoffs | 01:19
Watch as the headliners for the big UFC 197 event on March 5 face off for the first time at a media event in Las Vegas.
USA TODAY Sports
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCUFC champion Holly Holm endorses controversial company | 00:57
Holly Holm has inked a two-year deal to endorse Hi-Tech Pharmaceuticals, a supplement maker that sells products banned from UFC.
USA TODAY Sports
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCUFC 196 preview: Holly Holm vs. Miesha Tate | 00:39
MMAjunkie’s John Morgan breaks down the women’s bantamweight title fight on the big UFC 197 card.
USA TODAY Sports
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCUFC 196 preview: Conor McGregor vs. Rafael dos Anjos | 00:45
It’ll be champion vs. champion headlining the March mega card. MMAjunkie’s John Morgan breaks down the fight.
USA TODAY Sports
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCWhat was with all the UFC champs losing in 2015? | 02:24
Seven champions fell this year, including Ronda Rousey and Jose Aldo. Ben Fowlkes ponders, what gives?
USA TODAY Sports
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCConor McGregor on being the Mayweather, Pacquiao of UFC | 01:37
The new featherweight champion doesn’t hold back on where he thinks he ranks after his big win at UFC 194 over Jose Aldo.
USA TODAY Sports
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCConor McGregor discusses UFC 194 win, what’s next | 04:45
The new UFC featherweight champion recaps his huge win over Jose Aldo, as well as ponders what’s next for him.
USA TODAY Sports
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCRonda Rousey having hard time eating after loss to Holly Holm | 00:41
Ultimate Fighting Champion star-turned-actress Ronda Rousey is still struggling to eat almost a month after her brutal knockout defeat by Holly Holm.
Wochit
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCDana White, Holly Holm agree Ronda Rousey deserves rematch | 00:54
We can’t wait for that UFC fight.
USA TODAY Sports
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCRonda Rousey predicted KO loss to Jimmy Fallon | 00:30
She wasn’t ready for Holly Holm.
USA TODAY Sports
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCDana White reacts to Holly Holm’s stunning win at UFC 193 | 01:56
UFC president was just as stunned as everyone else after Holly Holm knocked out previously unbeaten Ronda Rousey.
USA TODAY Sports
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCMeet UFC fighter Holly Holm, ‘The Preacher’s Daughter’ | 04:14
USA TODAY Sports’ Martin Rogers’ one-on-one interview with Holm about her life outside of fighting.
USA TODAY Sports
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCRonda Rousey: From tending bars to breaking arms | 01:33
Following the 2008 Olympics, Ronda Rousey was broke. A chance encounter led to a job as a bartender, which gave her time to get back into mixed martial arts.
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCUFC’s Ronda Rousey to star in ‘Road House’ reboot | 00:38
It looks like UFC women’s champion Ronda Rousey is adding another Hollywood role to her resume.
USA TODAY
VIDEO PLAYLIST: LATEST FROM THE UFCRonda Rousey’s life story is becoming a movie | 00:26
Rousey will play herself in the biopic.
USA TODAY Sports
Last VideoNext Video